White Sox are setting up for a big offseason move, after quickly shedding past misfires

Posted

The organizations he’s hired people away from were a hint, but White Sox general manager Chris Getz has been open about where his influences lie.

“I find it really fascinating when you've got the Tampa Bay Rays, the Milwaukee Brewers, the Cleveland Guardians that are at the top of their divisions on a regular basis,” Getz told me this spring.

He stipulated there are lessons to take from the Dodgers and Yankees as well, but the last two years of White Sox baseball have operated closer to the Brewers and Rays, both in terms of payroll and how transaction-heavy they have been.

Part of how those teams have remained competitive despite payroll limitations is an unhesitant, unsentimental approach to doing business, at least in terms of swinging trades and making moves. These clubs don’t feel they can afford to carry many high salaries, and err on the side of cutting ties too soon, rather than footing the bill for cutting ties too late.

The three greatest players in Rays history–Evan Longoria, Carl Crawford, Ben Zobrist–all played the bulk of their 30s elsewhere. Brewers manager Pat Murphy went viral for joking about NLCS MVP Jake Bauers’ imminent departure in free agency while confetti was literally still falling down on both of them. When assistant general manager Carlos Rodriguez–who spent 16 years with the Rays, of course–was first introduced to the media in February, I asked if he foresaw the White Sox adapting a similar wheeling-and-dealing nature.

Rodriguez mostly demurred on declaring the franchise’s approach during his second month on the job, but his answer is interesting to apply to the Sox’ most recent trade of Luis Castillo and Davis Martin to the Rockies for two middling prospects.

“If it means making a transaction that allows the organization and the team to be more competitive or add more wins, whether it’s this year, or in the future, those are shots we will hopefully be able to take,” Rodriguez said.

With apologies to left-hander Sean Sullivan’s deceptive delivery and Douglas Veliz’s encouraging Dominican Summer League stats, the trade the Sox pulled on Thursday night clearly didn’t add wins in a vacuum. The Sox wanted to dump Castillo’s salary upon the Rockies, and paid them the price of a very affordable, solid-average starter in Davis Martin to do it. The value of the trade will be defined by the future signings it enables, for a Sox team that wants to land impact starting pitching in the free-agent market, while staying within their budget.

Losing Martin’s clubhouse presence, a pitcher Getz discussed as someone he uniquely trusted for his insight on the team’s needs, is an intangible cost that’s hard to measure. But what Getz has really shown he won’t be sentimental toward is his own ideas.

Four months ago, Getz sold Castillo as a boon to the White Sox rotation despite 2026 numbers that were the worst of his career, and now has conceded it was necessary to move on. The deal to acquire Castillo was itself a concession that a two-year, $20 million free-agent contract to make Seranthony Dominguez their closer hadn’t worked, and dumping his contract on the Mariners was better than hoping for a turnaround. To go even further, Dominguez was acquired with money freed up when Luis Robert Jr. was traded to the Mets in a salary dump which conceded the Sox could no longer wait for a 2023 redux.

A pessimistic–but not unfair–view is digging out from under this string of misses have cost the Sox both Martin and an interesting power-hitting prospect in Boston Smith, who went to Seattle in the Castillo trade. A rosier outlook is to compare how the Sox roster would look if they refused to surrender on any of these projects, to this present reality where they look primed to try to redeem it all with potentially the biggest investment in a free-agent starting pitcher in franchise history.

The latter is a lot more compelling. It’s just that the skill of quickly pivoting off misses won’t be as useful for nailing this one.