“It was better before.” This refrain has spanned generations since man knew how to sing. The psychological mechanism underlying it is self-protection: over time, our memory tends to attenuate the negative emotions linked to a memory. So much the better, otherwise the planet would only be populated by depressives!
In reality, affirming that “it was better before” speaks less of the past than of the future: it is a cry from the heart to demand more security, reference points and, let’s be crazy, happiness in the face of the dizziness of a world that changes too quickly.
The debate is not new: already in 1687, the quarrel between the Ancients and the Moderns pitted admirers of Antiquity against the champions of progress. Three centuries later, with the emergence of generative artificial intelligence, the dispute is still as lively as ever. It even takes on a dizzying dimension.
Let us project ourselves into 2126: what must we do today so that our great-grandchildren do not say: “It was better before”? (Note this questionable but optimistic presupposition: I am betting that we will have descendants.) Artificial intelligences will assist doctors, write some of the judgments, lessons, contracts, media (here, also note, I am no longer talking about newspapers). They could make care more effective, work less arduous and access to knowledge almost unlimited.
But no artificial intelligence can relieve us of our moral responsibilities. She doesn’t know, on her own, what is worth saving. It can democratize knowledge or, on the contrary, concentrate power in the wrong hands. It can help a student learn or accustom them to no longer searching for themselves. It can create new professions, but also massively eliminate jobs.
A century from now, our descendants probably won’t blame us for inventing artificial intelligence. But they risk asking us embarrassing questions: why did you accept that speed trumps truth, productivity trumps copyright, automation trumps jobs? Why did you train docile users rather than discerning citizens?
True progress will not come from having created systems that are smarter than us. It will be to have built a society which will give our descendants more reasons to hope than to regret.
And you, do you think it will be better afterwards? What would you absolutely love to preserve about our world for future generations? Share your opinion in our comments area. The most relevant will be read on LFM this Friday.
Valérie Ogier and Jean-Marc Richard give the floor to listeners, Monday to Friday from 12 p.m. to 1 p.m., on LFM.
Your voice deserves to be heard. Expand your views here.
The post The refrain “It was better before” especially questions our future appeared first on Carroll County Observer.